Another WUD controversy


Will our liberal campus support full-fledged free speech going into the future, even when it may be inconvenient? WUD responded clearly in the affirmative today in choosing to bring anti-Islamic speaker Ayaan Hirsi Ali to campus.

The controversy is, as always, whether this will promote hatred toward and the discrimination of Muslims on campus. Why risk this? Ross Douthat provides one of the best answers:

And the differences between religions are worth debating. Theology has consequences: It shapes lives, families, nations, cultures, wars; it can change people, save them from themselves, and sometimes warp or even destroy them.

Better yet.

In practice, the admirable principle that nobody should be persecuted for their beliefs often blurs into the more illiberal idea that nobody should ever publicly criticize another religion.

This is about ensuring an open dialogue on campus, sure, but it is also about being able to address one of the most important of all questions. This woman isn’t presenting bigotry. She is a scholar with real experiences and arguments. Will the lecture make people think poorly of the Muslim religion and those who practice it? Maybe, maybe not. All one can say is, tough, but welcome to the marketplace of ideas, ask the Catholic church about whether it is always nice to religion.


Tags: ,

One Response to “Another WUD controversy”

  1. Eric Schmidt Says:

    Slocum, thanks for the post about this DLS event. I should add that the number of confirmed guests on Facebook rose today from 150 to 250 — relatively unprecedented, and indicative of a spike in interest. In my past experience as DLS committee director from 2008-2009, it was my impression that most events which had 250-300 “confirmed guests” on Facebook by event time ended up selling out the 1300-seat Union Theatre. Bottom line: this is huge.

    Tickets are available on Tuesday, January 26th, at the Memorial Union Box Office on Park St. I expect them to go very, very fast, especially once campus is plastered with huge Ayaan Hirsi Ali posters.

    Here’s the link to the Facebook event:

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: